Fire Island’s finest bayfront dining in Ocean Beach, NY     631-583-8800      Lunch served daily - Noon til 5pm     Dinner served daily - 5:30pm til 10pm     Bar & Dancefloor til 4am
  • Like us on Facebook

Lobsterpalooza Thursdays

Three course meal including a cup of soup, dinner salad and a choice of 1 1/4 lb lobster or prime rib, served with corn on the cob, baked potato and freshly baked bread.

$29.75 per person (+tax & gratuity)

A Fire Island institution celebrating its 18th year!

Taste of Fire Island (TOFI) Prix Fixe

All summer Monday – Thursday
All dinners include soup du jour and salad for $29.75

Choice of Cup of New England Clam Chowder or Soup Du Jour

Choice of Garden Salad or Caesar Salad


Grilled Skirt Steak†
Roast shallot demi glace, haricot vert, roast garlic mashed potatoes

Drunken Pork Chop†
Rum marinade, Bali BBQ sauce, mango puree, haricot vert, roast garlic
mashed potatoes

Penne Pasta
Spicy Italian sausage, spinach, roast shallots, fennel, crimini mushrooms,
roast plum tomatoes
Available without sausage

Roast Free-Range Chicken†
All natural Bell & Evans chicken, roast garlic mashed potatoes, haricot vert,
aged sherry vinegar, morel mushroom sauce

Grilled Salmon Filet†
Baby arugala greens, watermelon, feta cheese, pickled fennel, toasted almonds,
white balsamic vinaigrette

Pan Seared Mediterranean Sea Bass†
Oven dried tomatoes and giant white bean ragout, caponata vegetables,
gremolata garnish

†Gluten Free

Happy Appy Hour

Monday-Thursday 3-5pm
Come Get Happy at Maguire’s –
Soak up the Sun on our Huge Back Deck!

$4 Miller Lites, $6 Frozens, $17 Mag’s Steam Bucket: Mussels, Steamers, and Clams
and 25% off all appetizers

Fire Island’s
Only Late Night Happy Hour

Friday & Saturday nights
$4 Miller Lites
$6 well drinks
from 11pm-1am